Skip to content
Submit
Close search
Home
Order
expand
collapse
Order
Order Pies
Order Gelato
Farm to Stoop
Our Craft Pantry
Cookie Box
Party Gear
About Us
expand
collapse
About Us
Who We Are
Hours & Locations
How We Make It
Gelato Photoshoot: A Taste For Adventure: Winter
Gelato Photoshoot: A Taste For Adventure: Summer
Press
Events
Contact
FREE same day delivery on ALL orders above $29.99 (Good for both JC & HBK)
Home
Order
expand
Order Pies
Order Gelato
Farm to Stoop
Our Craft Pantry
Cookie Box
Party Gear
About Us
expand
Who We Are
Hours & Locations
How We Make It
Gelato Photoshoot: A Taste For Adventure: Winter
Gelato Photoshoot: A Taste For Adventure: Summer
Press
Events
Contact
Submit
Search
Log in
Cart
Cart
0
items
expand/collapse
Craft Gelato
Craft Gelato, Made from Scratch
Filter
Filter
baked goods
Pints
23 products
Sort
Sort
Featured
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Deep Dark Chocolate
$13.00
Bucket & Bay Vanilla
$13.00
Mint Chip Classic
$13.00
RedEye [coffee]
$13.00
BLACK LABEL Vanilla
$13.00
Flat Cones = Gluten-free Pizzelles (x5)
Regular price
$3.95
Rose Latte Gelato
$13.00
LIMITED EDITION: Macallan Gelato
Regular price
$14.00
Toasted Coconut
$13.00
Vanilla Brownie Gelato
Regular price
$13.00
Gluten-Free Brownie
Regular price
$4.25
Sold out
VINTNERS SERIES: Strawberry Port
Regular price
$14.00
Ginger Molasses Cookies (x4)
Regular price
$3.00
Honeydew Sorbet (v)
Regular price
$13.00
Chocolate Brownie
Regular price
$13.00
LIMITED EDITION: For Goodness Sake!
Regular price
$14.00
Lemon Spritzer
Regular price
$14.00
Sold out
Lemon Sorbet (v)
Regular price
$13.00
Milk & Peanut Butter Cookies Gelato
Regular price
$13.00
Milk & Chocolate Chip Cookies Gelato
Regular price
$13.00
COOKIE BOX - 4 x Milk & Cookies Gelato + Cookies
Regular price
$55.00
Milk & Old Fashioned Oatmeal Cookie Gelato
Regular price
$13.00
Milk & Rainbow Sprinkle Sugar Cookie Gelato
Regular price
$13.00
![RedEye [coffee] - Pie 66 - concept shop by Bucket & Bay Craft Gelato Co](http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1499/8276/products/RedEye-prd_195x.jpg?v=1587050575)
